III. Direct Tax Case laws:
1. ACIT Vs. Shri Dharam Pal Gulati, ITA No. 671/Del/2012, Date of Pronouncement: 20.06.2013, A.Y. 2007-08, ITAT- Delhi
Section: 132(4) of the Income Tax act, 1961
Whether
the addition made by AO merely on the basis of statement recorded u/s
132(4) of the Act which was retracted immediately thereafter and no
supporting evidences are found during search operation, is justified.
Held_No
There
was no incriminating document or supporting document found or seized
during the search operation carried out at the premises of the assessee
which could suggest that assessee was doing the business of speculation
in commodities during the relevant period stated in statement.
Therefore, such additions made only on the basis of a statement which
has been retracted immediately thereafter are not sustainable. Further,
there was sufficient time with the Investigation Wing to carry on the
investigation and to collect the evidence against the retraction but
records show that nothing has been done in this regard. In such a
situation, the retraction of the assessee can not be said to be invalid
in absence of any incriminating documents.
(Please click here for judgment)
2. ACIT Vs. Tirupati Udyog Ltd., ITA No. 2610/Del/2012, Date of Pronouncement: 20.06.2013, A.Y. 2008-09, ITAT-Delhi
Whether
the amount of compensation received for termination of Memorandum of
Understanding (MoU) which enables the assessee to carry on the business
of mining is a capital receipt on account of loss of “source of income”.
Held_Yes
The
assessee was not in this line of business and was in the business of
manufacturing and trading. The assessee chose to enter into a new line
of business by way of this MOU. The essence of the MOU is to enable the
assessee to carry on the business of mining and cancellation of the
agreement in question deprives the assessee of what is a substantive
source of income from mining. Since, it is a loss of source of income
from mining, thus the amount received as compensation by the assessee is
a capital receipt.
(Please click here for judgment)
|