1. Trilok
Chand Girdharilal & Party Vs. Income-tax Officer, IT Appeal No. 577
of 2009, Date of Order: 21.01.2014, High Court of Rajasthan
Assessee
not maintaining sale vouchers, rejection of assessee's account books
and trading results by invoking provisions of section 145(3) was
justified and Commissioner (Appeals) had rightly applied average gross
profit rate in instant case.
When the sale
vouchers have not been maintained or issued, then certainly provisions
of section 145(3) can be invoked by the revenue. The assessee cannot
contend that when all other things are fully proved and only because
sale vouchers are lacking then book results cannot be rejected. The
Assessing Officer applied gross profit rate on the basis of certain
comparable cases. The Commissioner (Appeals) after appreciation of
evidence on record applied average gross profit rate as declared by the
assessee and the other comparable cases relied upon by the assessee as
well as the Assessing Officer. Therefore, there was no other alternate
with the Commissioner (Appeals) in a case like this to have adopted an
average gross profit rate, which has been upheld by the Tribunal.
(Please click here for judgment)
2. Shri Gopilal Laddha Vs. ACIT, I.T.A. No. 1356/Bang/2012, Date of Pronouncement: 31.10.2013, ITAT – Banglore
For the purpose section 54F, relevant date of investment in new house is the date of Registered sale deed.
The issues
raised by the authorities below to deny the assessee the said exemption
u/s.54F viz. (i) that the booking for the said flat was made by the
assessee on 19.1.2006; (ii) that a loan of Rs.40 lakhs was taken from
Syndicate Bank on 24.5.2006 towards investment in the said flat being
more than one year, prior to sale acquisition of the said property on
21.7.2008, the learned Authorised Representative submits, is not
material, since the assessee has acquired the new property i.e. ;the
flat, only on 11.9.2008 by Registered Sale beed and not before that,
Held Yes, since The assessee has been vested with the ownership of the
new flat at Gokulam, Kanakpura Road only by virtue of the Registered
Sale deed
(Please click here for judgment)